How we check jobs

We read each employer’s own job board every day. Every warning comes with its reason, so you can judge for yourself.

Example job (made up), with all its checks opened.
Registered Nurse, Med-Surg NightsBayside General Hospital · Tampa, FL · Full-time
$38–$52/hr

Looks real. 1 thing to check before you apply.

  • On the company’s own careers siteGreenhouse board
  • Checked open todayLive check
  • Pay range listed: $38–$52/hrJob posting
  • Open for 7 months · −20Long-open jobs are sometimes already filled. Ask when they plan to hire.
    −20
Trust score 80 / 100 · Looks good
  1. Where it’s postedThe employer’s own careers site, not a copy on another board.
  2. Open statusWe read the employer’s board every day, and check live when we can. “Checked open today” means we saw it open in the last 24 hours; an older sighting says when.
  3. PayListed or not, and whether the law likely requires it.
  4. Things to checkEach warning says what we saw and what to ask.
  5. The score in one wordOut of 100, with the same word on cards, job pages and the filter.

What takes points off

Every job starts at 100. Each sign below takes points off.

  • RepostsThe same job taken down and put back up. One repost is common, so it counts from the second.−15 each from the 2nd, up to −45
  • Gone from the employer’s boardStill listed elsewhere.−40
  • Open for monthsFrom 2 months to 2 years, counted from the employer’s own publish date when it gives one.−5 to −35
  • “Always hiring” wording“Talent pool”, “always accepting applications”.−20
  • Many brands, one boardOne account posting entry-level jobs for many firms. Labelled as an agency, after a person reviews the account.−20
  • Same ad in many placesShown as one listing. Nothing off for one ad per store.−15
  • Gig or contractor platformHundreds of near-identical gig or contractor roles from one account. Only after a person reviews the account; not labelled as an agency.−15
  • Commission-only payNo base salary or hourly wage.−10
  • Hiring slowdownThe company’s open roles fell 40% or more in 60 days.−10
  • No pay where the law likely requires itTakes the place of “No pay listed”.−10
  • No pay listedA weak sign on its own.−5
  • Good sign: a real vacancyThe posting says it fills an existing role.+10
Every rule, point by point
  • Reposts. The same job taken down and put back up. Each repost takes off 15 points, up to 45.
  • Long-open listings. Counted from the employer’s own publish date when their job board gives one, otherwise from when we first saw it: 2 months+ 5 points, 3 months+ 10 points, 6 months+ 20 points, 12 months+ 25 points, 2 years+ 35 points. A listing open for 2 years or more can reach “Check details” on age alone. The exception is a chain’s one-ad-per-store requisitions (below): their age takes off at most 25 points.
  • “Always hiring” language. Phrases like “always accepting applications” or “talent pool” (20 points).
  • Hiring slowdowns. The company’s open roles fell by 40%+ in 60 days (10 points).
  • Missing pay where the law likely requires it. 10 points.
  • No pay range listed. A weak sign on its own, so it takes off only 5 points, and a job can still score Looks good with it. Pay we can’t read reliably (“Pay unclear”, or another currency on a US job) counts as not listed. Where the law likely requires a range, the stronger warning above applies instead, and commission-only pay has its own check below.
  • Commission-only pay. The posting says pay is commission only, with no base salary or hourly wage (10 points). Its figures are shown as earnings, not salary, and left out of pay filters and typical pay.
  • Gone from the employer’s own board. 40 points.
  • Same ad in many places. One employer posts the same ad text in many places at once, often the same day (15 points). We show it as one listing. A chain that posts one ad per store (store numbers or addresses, stores, food service, warehouses, or ads added over weeks rather than in one day) loses no points; we note “This chain posts one ad per store” instead.
  • Many brands, one board. One account posts hundreds of entry-level marketing, events, sales or customer service jobs across many cities, and the ads name several different firms as the employer (20 points). We label it as an agency. A person reviews each account before the sign shows.
  • Gig or contractor platform. One account posts hundreds of near-identical gig or contractor roles across many cities, worded as gig work, independent contractor or 1099 roles, paid per task or per delivery, or with hours you choose yourself (15 points). We don’t label it as an agency. A person reviews each account before the sign shows.
  • Good sign: the posting says it’s for an existing vacancy (adds back 10 points).

What the score means

What’s left of the 100, in one word.

  • Strong90–100Few or no warning signs in what we checked. The job page lists every check.
  • Looks good70–89A few things to check, each listed with its reason.
  • Check details50–69Several warning signs. Read the reasons before you apply.
  • Proceed with cautionunder 50Many warning signs. Ask the employer about each one before you share details.
  • Not scored yetThe job page says when the score will be ready.
  • Signs of a scamShown first on any job, whatever the score.
What Strong needs, and when there’s no score

No warning signs isn’t enough for Strong. A job also needs a live check in the last 14 days that found it open on the employer’s site, plus listed pay or 14 days of our own history without a repost. Until then it stops at 89, Looks good.

“Not scored yet” means we have too little to go on: a score needs at least 2 of a live check, 7 days of history and a rule that fired. The “Looks good or better” filter keeps Strong and Looks good jobs. The score counts signals about this listing; it is not a verdict about the employer, and a low score doesn’t mean a job is fake.

Layoff notices (WARN) and SEC restructuring filings

Facts about the employer, not the listing, so they never change a job’s score. Company pages show both.

Found
The notice or filing, with its date, place and size, and a link to the source.
None found
With how far each state’s list goes: states publish late.
Not checked
Said plainly when we don’t read that state’s list or can’t match an SEC filer. Neither means the record is clean.
Where they come from and what we show
  • WARN notices. Under the federal WARN Act, larger employers must give 60 days’ notice of a mass layoff or a site closing, and states publish the notices. We read the lists of CA, IN, NJ, PA, TX and WA and match notices to employers by company name and location; a match we aren’t sure of waits for a person to review it.
  • SEC restructuring filings. Public companies report restructuring costs (exit or disposal costs, often with layoffs) on Form 8-K, Item 2.05. We read each matched company’s filings on SEC EDGAR.
  • Found: a job page adds one line when the employer has either in the last 12 months.
  • None found: “No WARN notices found in the CA, IN, NJ, PA, TX and WA lists in the last 12 months”. We show the list’s own newest date, not the day we read it. For SEC: “No SEC reports of restructuring costs in the last 12 months”.
  • Not checked: “We don’t check layoff notices for Ohio yet” when the employer has no location in a state we read or is based in a state we don’t read, and “We couldn’t match this company to an SEC filer” when we hold no SEC match (private companies, and public ones we haven’t matched).

What we never do

  • Take money from employers to rank jobs higher
  • Show sponsored listings
  • Add details about recruiters or other people beyond what the employer published

See the checks on real jobs

Search checked jobs